Chicago’s Italian Beef Sandwiches
by Phyllis Zeck
Four words that can make you salivate: Chicago’s Italian Beef Sandwiches! No other beef sandwich comes close to the ones made by our family.
You bite into your sandwich and taste the tender beef, the sweet green peppers, and you hear the juice drip down on your plate. You wrap the yellow crackling paper tighter around the sandwich so nothing else escapes. You can’t help it – a huge smile spreads over your face. You feel like you are in Heaven. You finish your sandwich. It’s gone. It’s over. How long until you can eat the next one?
The original Italian beef sandwich recipe spans three generations and was created by Edith (Luke and Muriel’s mother) and Margie (John’s daughter). Edith made beef sandwiches for “the guys” when they would come over to play cards which spawned the idea for Edith and Margie to open a restaurant.
Margie and her husband Al Vitullo opened Margie’s beef stand at 1324 Cicero Ave. Margie’s Italian Lemonade was next door, behind the beef stand and lunch time meant lines of customers trailed out the doors at both locations. Luke remembers making fresh lemonade every day all year round. Customer’s bought the lemonade by the pint container for 15 cents. Margie and Al lived a few doors down from the restaurant at 1354 N. Cicero Ave. The original Margie’s was sold, burned down in 1987, then became a car lot.
Frank Jr (Luke) began his restaurant in 1965 and now has restaurants in Tucson AZ. Luke is still working full time, he says he doesn’t know what he’d do with himself if he retired. I
Luke’s two sons Joel and Cary operate branches in the Phoenix area his son Matt owns a restaurant in Elkhorn WI.
Luke’s sister Muriel and her husband Justin Fortuna opened their stand in 1976 in Harwood Heights. The restaurant is named after Muriel and Justin’s son Jay who now runs it. You’ll find Muriel still putting in a full day’s work behind the counter.










Comments
These are wonderful pictures, thanks for More...
thank you for your comment. It’s alway More...
Gemma was Auntie Phyllis' Godmother. More...
Such a beautiful story! Thank you for sh More...
Phyllis..... Thank You for Posting My Ph More...